Weight cutting failures have become a troubling habit in mixed martial arts. Almost every event features at least one fighter who fails to make weight. The recent card in Rio, however, pushed that issue to new extremes.
The night opened with Luan Lacerda facing Saimon Oliveira — who missed the bantamweight limit by a shocking eight pounds. The contest took place at 144 pounds, which made it more like a featherweight fight. Oliveira even had to stay below an adjusted weight just to keep the bout alive.
Lacerda still won, dismissing any talk of fighters missing weight intentionally for an edge. He also avoided the usual payment complications. Meanwhile, Oliveira looked drained and defeated, leaving his career with the promotion in serious doubt.
Why Current Penalties Don’t Work
Even with Oliveira’s heavy punishment, the system remains weak. He lost 50 percent of his purse — far more than the usual 20 to 30 percent deduction. The fine sent a message but didn’t fix the root problem.
Too many fighters still gamble with dangerous weight cuts, hoping the risk pays off. That attitude undermines fairness and athlete safety. The sport needs a uniform and tougher set of penalties that make missing weight a truly costly mistake.
Increasing Fines for Repeat Offenders
A fair solution would be to raise fines for every repeat offense. Bigger weight misses already lead to bigger fines, but repeat offenders should pay even more.
Under this approach, the first miss costs 20 percent of the purse. The second would jump to 25 percent, and the third to 30 percent or higher. In extreme cases, the penalty could reach even greater amounts.
Charles Oliveira’s history offers an example. His first miss against Cub Swanson in 2012 would have brought a 20 percent fine. Missing weight again against Jeremy Stephens would mean 25 percent, while the third time — against Myles Jury — would cost at least 30 percent.
A time window could make the system fairer. For example, a 12- to 18-month limit could reset a fighter’s penalty. But a repeat miss within that span would increase the fine automatically.
Forcing Fighters to Move Up a Division
If fighters continue to rely on extreme weight cuts, stronger action is needed. A second miss should lead to a mandatory move to a higher weight class. No exceptions, no second chances.
Whether the fighter is on the undercard or close to a title shot, two misses should end their run in that division. They must move up or lose their license to fight.
This rule might appear strict, but it protects both health and fairness. Massive cuts harm the body and distort competition. The California State Athletic Commission already monitors rehydration and can cancel fights for severe weight issues. Extending similar rules across the sport would make MMA safer and more credible.
Introducing an Automatic One-Point Deduction
The harshest but possibly most effective measure would be an automatic one-point deduction at the start of the fight. The referee would announce it immediately as the bout begins. The fighter who missed weight could only score a maximum of nine points in the first round.
This rule would force fighters to dominate the fight completely to win a decision. Losing a single round could lead only to a draw at best. That kind of disadvantage would make weight misses far less tempting.
The Professional Fighters League has already experimented with similar ideas. In its tournament system, fighters who missed weight lost points in the standings. Later, they were barred from earning any at all. The change was controversial, but it proved that strict consequences can change behavior.
Professionalism Must Return to the Scale
Making weight is part of a fighter’s job. It shows discipline, preparation, and respect for the opponent. Fighters who meet their marks deserve protection from those who don’t.
To restore fairness, the sport must enforce stronger penalties. Whether through higher fines, forced division changes, or automatic point deductions, leniency can no longer be an option.
Missing weight is not just a number on the scale. It’s a sign of poor preparation and lost professionalism. For the sport’s future — and the safety of its fighters — tough rules are the only way forward.
